MLB 25’s Tallest Team Ever: When Size Becomes a Strategy

In the long history of baseball—both real and virtual—teams have been built around speed, power, defense, or pitching depth. Rarely, however, has height itself felt like a defining strategy. In MLB The Show 25 Stubs, that changes dramatically with the construction of what may be the tallest team ever assembled in the game’s history. This lineup isn’t just big—it’s towering. Every position is filled by mammoth athletes who look less like traditional ballplayers and more like they wandered over from an NBA tryout.

At the center of this experiment is a simple but fascinating question: Does size intimidate, disrupt, and dominate in MLB 25’s ranked environment—or does it create unexpected weaknesses?

A Lineup That Touches the Clouds

Let’s start with the obvious. This team is enormous.

Most of the position players stand at 6’7 or taller, with Richie Sexson headlining the squad at 6’8—the same height as LeBron James. It’s impossible not to ask the question: Did any of these guys ever consider basketball? Dunking seems like it would’ve been a casual hobby for half the roster.

But instead of hardwood courts, these giants found success on the diamond—and in MLB 25, that size translates into a lineup that visually overwhelms opponents before a single pitch is thrown.

Every batter looms over the plate. Strike zones feel different. Pitchers look smaller by comparison. Even standard fastballs seem to vanish into these massive frames, swallowed up by long arms and broad shoulders. From a purely psychological standpoint, this team already has an edge.

Intimidation as a Meta Weapon

Baseball has always been a mental game, and MLB 25 captures that better than ever. Facing a lineup full of players who all look like cleanup hitters can be unsettling, especially in ranked play where pressure already runs high.

There’s something uniquely uncomfortable about watching pitch after pitch approach hitters who barely need to crouch. Tall players naturally compress the visual strike zone, forcing opponents to be more precise. Miss your spot, and the ball is leaving the yard.

Even before the first inning ends, opponents may start pressing—throwing riskier pitches, nibbling at corners, or abandoning their game plan entirely. That’s where intimidation becomes a real strategy, even if it’s never listed on a stat sheet.

Richie Sexson: The Colossus at the Core

Richie Sexson is the embodiment of this build. At 6’8, he stands as the tallest position player on the roster and one of the tallest hitters in MLB 25 altogether. His presence alone changes the dynamic of an at-bat.

Sexson’s long swing path creates terrifying power potential, especially on pitches left up in the zone. In MLB 25’s hitting engine, taller hitters often generate explosive exit velocity when timing is right—and Sexson thrives in that sweet spot.

But he’s not just a novelty. His height gives him reach, plate coverage, and the ability to turn borderline pitches into damage. Facing him late in a close-ranked game can feel like walking a tightrope.

Height Beyond the Batter’s Box

What truly separates this team from a gimmick lineup is that the size advantage extends well beyond the batting order. This is a fully committed build—from starters to bullpen arms.

At the top of the rotation sits Randy Johnson, appropriately nicknamed “The Big Unit.” Already one of the most intimidating pitchers in baseball history, Johnson’s height amplifies everything MLB 25 does well with pitching realism.

From his release point, fastballs appear to explode downward toward the plate, while sliders sweep violently out of the zone. His long stride shortens reaction time, making him a nightmare for hitters who are even slightly late on their reads.

Johnson alone is enough to tilt a ranked match in your favor—but when paired with a bullpen equally packed with giants, the pressure never lets up.

A Bullpen of Giants

The bullpen might be the most absurd part of this entire experiment.

Nearly every reliever stands 6’8 or taller, with one towering presence reaching an incredible 6’11. Watching these pitchers jog in from the bullpen feels surreal—like watching skyscrapers take the mound.

In MLB 25, pitcher height influences release point, perceived velocity, and pitch plane. Tall relievers create sharper vertical movement, especially on sinkers and high fastballs. Combine that with late-inning tension, and opponents often find themselves swinging under pitches they swear were strikes.

It’s not just about raw stats. It’s about discomfort. Hitters don’t get comfortable. They don’t settle in. Every at-bat feels slightly off, and over nine innings, that adds up.

Ranked Play Anxiety: When Intimidation Cuts Both Ways

Of course, running a team like this in ranked play comes with its own nerves.

There’s a strange irony in fielding a lineup so intimidating that you start feeling the pressure. When expectations rise, mistakes feel heavier. Every run allowed feels like it shouldn’t have happened. Every missed swing feels amplified.

There’s also the unspoken fear: what if opponents react badly? What if the sheer dominance feels unfair? What if someone reports you—not for cheating, but for psychological warfare?

It’s a humorous thought, but it highlights something important about MLB 25’s competitive space. Intimidation is real. Presentation matters. And when a team looks this overwhelming, emotions run hotter on both sides of the screen.

Strengths of the Tall-Team Build

From a gameplay standpoint, this roster brings several undeniable advantages:

Power at every position: Long levers mean higher home-run potential across the lineup.

Strike zone manipulation: Taller hitters force pitchers to work harder at the edges.

Pitching deception: High release points and steep pitch angles disrupt timing.

Psychological dominance: Opponents feel pressured before the game even settles.

In a meta often dominated by speed builds and contact hitters, this approach feels refreshingly different—and surprisingly effective.

The Hidden Weaknesses

That said, height isn’t a magic button.

Tall players can struggle with:

Low pitches, especially breaking balls that dive below the knees.

Reaction time on inside pitches is due to longer swing paths.

Defense in certain positions, particularly at shortstop or second base, where lateral quickness matters.

MLB 25 does a solid job balancing player models, and not every giant moves like a gazelle. Smart opponents will exploit these weaknesses, especially if they stay disciplined and avoid pitching scared.

A Statement More Than a Strategy

What makes this tallest-team build so compelling isn’t just whether it wins—it’s what it represents.

In MLB 25, it’s easy to chase meta lineups and optimized stats. This team does something different. It turns physical presence into identity. It leans into intimidation, spectacle, and the sheer fun of fielding players who look like they were built in a lab buy MLB 25 Stubs.

Win or lose, every ranked game becomes memorable. Every opponent remembers the lineup they faced. Every home run feels heavier. Every strikeout feels more final.

Final Thoughts: Bigger Than Baseball

At the end of the day, this towering roster proves something important about MLB 25: there’s still room for creativity, personality, and experimentation.

Whether you’re nervously hopping into ranked play or confidently letting your giants loom over the competition, this team reminds us why sports games are at their best when they let players express bold ideas.

It might be the tallest team in MLB history.

It might be intimidating.

It might even make opponents a little uncomfortable.

But that’s baseball. And in MLB 25, sometimes bigger really is better.